| |
|
|
| |
Education World
| March 2003 |
|
| |
|
|
| |
 |
|
 |
| |
|
|
| |
Educators Review SmartDraw: SmartDraw,
a software application from SmartDraw.com, allows users
to create charts, diagrams, timelines, technical drawings,
and a variety of professional-looking documents and
presentations. Recently, Education World reviewers checked
out SmartDraw and found a myriad of uses for the software,
both in their personal and professional lives. Our reviewers
rated the software on a scale of 1-4 and shared their
thoughts about the program's strengths and weaknesses.
This is what they had to say!
SmartDraw by SmartDraw.com is a software program for
creating charts, diagrams, timelines, flowcharts, technical
drawings, documents, and presentations. The software
includes more than 50,000 symbols and clip art images,
as well as templates and tutorials. With SmartDraw,
you can create newsletters, maps, labels, posters, and
more ¡X and then publish your work on your free SmartDraw
Web space.
Recently, Education World asked our reviewers, all teachers
or educational technology specialists, to check out
SmartDraw in actual classroom situations. Reviewers
were asked to use SmartDraw both in their personal and
professional lives for a period of at least one month,
note specific strengths, weaknesses, and/or quirks of
the program, record their observations ¡X both positive
and negative ¡X and rate various qualities of the software
on a scale of 1-4.
The results are in ¡X and this is what our reviewers
had to say!
OVERALL COMMENTS
"I really like this program. I used it years ago
for a networking class, and it helped so much for students
to actually design layouts with standard symbols used
in the real world. It brought meaning to the class when
they could actually print their diagram and hand it
to a professional and have them understand exactly what
was on the page."
"I used this software to prepare for a course I'll
be co-teaching next term with language arts preservice
teachers. I could easily see how classroom teachers
might use it create such materials as newsletters and
integrated timelines with their students."
"I would love to purchase this program for our
educational studies department. This one software piece
can be used instead of Microsoft Office, Inspiration,
Print Shop Deluxe, Microsoft Publisher, TimeLiner, Graph
Club, and more! When it comes to the presentation of
instructional materials, this program has the ability
to perform the tasks of four to five other applications."
"I used the networking library for training teachers
of networking classes. Participants drew an 'existing'
network layout, printed it as a visual aid, and then
revised the plan using SmartDraw. The participants were
very impressed with the software and with how easy it
was to use. I also demonstrated the software for technology
directors."
"I used the flier library to create information
to distribute. The end product looked very professional."
"I experimented with in the program and created
graphic organizers and flowcharts. They were surprisingly
easy to do. I especially like the automatic alignment
and sizing options."
"I would recommend the purchase of this program
for school use. The Professional Plus version includes
50,000 symbols and clip art images. This program could
be used in a lab setting by any grade level and in any
subject area. It is also a great administrative tool
¡X for both teachers and administrators. The other versions
can have libraries added on after purchase. This would
give a school district/user many options."
"I used SmartDraw to create handouts for student
use and to create a variety of images to include in
a PowerPoint presentation that will be used at a future
conference. Several students used the program to create
graphics for their graduation projects, and my husband
used it to generate illustrations for test questions."
"I have this program loaded on one machine that
is available for teacher use, and the teachers are fighting
over that specific machine ¡X they all want to use it."
"This software is very versatile and easy to learn
to use in a short amount of time. I used the program
to draw a living room floor plan; create a timeline
of actions steps for our district technology plan; create
a state map that students used Paint to add cities,
rivers, and regions to; and made some stationary. I
also created flowcharts and organizational charts."
"I used this program to create fliers; I imported
a picture into one of the frames and saved it as an
HTML file, which worked very well. I also saved some
drawings I made as gifs, which worked very well too.
The only feature I didn't like very much was the one
that allows you to e-mail what you create. If you use
the SmartDraw method (and don't export it into another
file format), you get a file that has to be viewed by
a SmartDraw viewer, which you have to get at the SmartDraw
site. It's a fast download and worked well, but I found
it to be an inconvenience."
"What did I like about SmartDraw?
- The software was fairly easy to learn to use. Many
of the tools were consistent with ones I often use
with MS products, Adobe, and Macromedia.
- The pop-up Advisor can be very helpful, and having
the option to turn it off is also important.
- I liked the linking feature for the charts, and
that items stay connected even when moved. Being able
to choose infinite connection points is also an important
option.
- The option that included adding text to a line was
wonderful. It made it easy to rearrange a chart and
have everything move with it.
- Using the arrow keys to 'nudge' items into position
is a great and useful option.
- Being able to add your own shapes or symbols to
the libraries is wonderful.
- The publishing options ¡X e-mailing a file with a
viewer, publishing to a Web page, or printing straight
from SmartDraw ¡X were many and worked conveniently.
- Having templates to edit ¡X and so many ¡X is great!
|
|
| |
What didn't I like? When I pasted data
from an Excel chart into a table, quotation marks appeared
in some cells. I also wanted to be able to sort the rows
in my chart by date, but sorting of any kind wasn't an
option I could find. My table spanned three pages and
I wanted to be able to insert page breaks for a 'cleaner'
publication, but that wasn't an option either." INSTALLATION
COMMENTS "In using this program with
Windows XP, I had to install it, uninstall it, and then
install it again, because it went to the serial number
dialogue box instead of to the program. On a second machine,
using the same operating system, it went just fine the
first time." "I didn't find any recommendations
or instructions for installing the other collections at
a later date. The installation defaults with one library
checked. You have the option of installing the others
and then you have options on each library as to what to
add. I didn't see anything explaining that you would need
to go through another installation, or that you could
import other libraries, or what the process might be.
The program did, however, show the size/space taken up
and how much was left when you checked the other libraries
you wanted to install." "I had a lot
of trouble loading the program. In the process, I blew
the motherboard on my laptop and ran into problems on
my desktop as well. I was finally able to load it completely
after the fourth attempt. In order to do that, I had to
copy files from the CD and place them on another drive
and run it from there. Evidently, something on the CD
was defective. Once the program was loaded, however, I
was able to use it with no further problems."
"I did not experience any difficulties installing
the program." "The program installed
completely without any problems, although it did seem
to take a while (possibly due to the vast amount of graphics)."
USABILITY COMMENTS "The software includes
good help tips, if the user wants them. Documentation
is excellent, if one takes the time to read it before
getting started with the software." "If
a user has any experience at all with any other drawing
program, including the drawing tools in MS Office, this
program will be easy to use. With the drag-and-drop interface,
even inexperienced or young users will have no problem."
"The Online Tutorial was helpful, but if
it would have been more useful it had been interactive.
Trying the options you are reading about would be more
beneficial for first time users." "The
Content Advisor and the Hints were annoying. The Content
Advisor takes up space. If it was a check box asking you
if you wanted to see it, instead of just being there,
I would have liked it better. The hints were useful at
first ¡X and they would be helpful for beginners ¡X but
they got in the way pretty fast. If there was an option
that automatically shut them off after the first ten times
the program was opened (or something like that), I would
like it better. That way, the user could turn them back
on instead of turning them off. The "opt out"
option is there; I would just like the process reversed."
"I like the continuity of processes; i.e.
commands are the same as in other software. (For example,
selecting multiple items is achieved by holding down shift
and selecting.) That makes the software easier to use
for most people." "I found the program
to be very useful for a variety of teachers, subjects,
and grade levels." "I had a bit of
a difficult time viewing the teeny pictures of graphics.
They are supposed to be viewed by double clicking, but
I kept forgetting that feature and thinking that I needed
to somehow see those teeny icons. It was probably more
my fault than the program's!" PERFORMANCE
COMMENTS "I had no problems the entire
time I used the software. I used the software in MS Office
¡X importing a chart I had created ¡X without a hitch. I
have had OLE type applications lock up before, but this
was a smooth operation." "Once it
was loaded, I had no problems!" "I
never experienced any bugs, lock ups, conflicts, or problems
with the software."
USEFULNESS COMMENTS "I am most impressed
with this software for use by preservice teachers. It
offers more than Microsoft Office for presenting materials
to students and families. In addition, the program offers
some of the same features as Tom Snyder's Graph Club and
TimeLiner." "I could never have created
on my own the graphs and drawing this program provided.
My husband, who generates questions for a national testing
company, also found it useful for illustrations, and so
on." "The educational price seemed
very reasonable to me. I think teachers, as well as middle-and
high-school students could benefit from this software.
Vocational technical students could use it for many purposes
too." "I can see students in middle
school and above using this software to enhance their
reports or other schoolwork; older students and professionals
would find this a handy piece of software to have on their
computers for presentations and the like."
"The more I played with this software, the more I
liked it. It is not for the faint of heart, however! There
are many libraries to check out and a bit of manipulating
around the canvas is needed to create a nice finished
piece." SUPPORT COMMENTS
"The Help menu provides a link to the SmartDraw Web
site, where you can find trial versions of the software
and register for e-mails with links to graphics."
"According to the documentation, technical
support is readily available, but I didn't use that option.
I did go to the Web site, however, to see what was offered;
there are many resources. I liked that fact that you can
download a manual and that there was a knowledge base.
I also like the software update options. This could save
a lot of time. Another plus is the free download of the
software. This would allow a teacher to actually try the
software first. A 30-day trial is enough time for someone
to become familiar with the software and even lead a workshop
to see if the other faculty/participants are enthusiastic
about the product." "I did not attempt
to contact the company to receive any live tech support;
I only accessed the help text provided with the software."
"This program was intuitive enough ¡X maybe
because I have played with other mapping software ¡X that
I didn't need to access help very much. I tend to play
more with the features as I go along to see what they
do." Linda Starr - Education
World |
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|